Beyond the business

By Barbara Spector

This issue's cover story subjects are different from the families usually profiled in Family Business. While we generally feature families who own an operating company, the Power family no longer are the owners of J.D. Power and Associates, the highly respected consumer survey business founded by patriarch Dave Power in 1968.

After the sale of J.D. Power to McGraw-Hill in 2005, Power family members formalized their family governance, formed a family limited partnership and began working with a multifamily office on investing as a family and educating the next generation. The Powers continue to work together on philanthropic activities, as well; they established a family foundation in 2005.

The Powers are using the proceeds from the sale of their business to generate new wealth and fund their foundation. They are working collaboratively as a family. Sounds like an American success story, right?

Of course it does—except that J.D. Power and Associates can be considered as one of the 87% of U.S. family businesses that did not survive into the third generation, according to frequently cited statistics compiled by family business researcher John L. Ward way back in 1987. Reliance on those statistics fails to take into account the fact that families like the Powers—and around the world there are many, many others like them—do not fit into a simplistic "survival or failure" binary.

A three-year global study of 118 family firm executives conducted under the auspices of the Family Firm Institute and completed in 2010 found that over their history, the participating families had owned an average of 6.1 companies and spun off an average of 1.5. I wrote about this study in the 2011 edition of Family Business Agenda. (The study was eventually published in the June 2012 issue of Family Business Review, an academic journal.)

The study, as I wrote in 2011, "aimed to reframe the view of family enterprise from a focus on operating companies to an assessment of value creation over time." The researchers concluded that the family, not the business, is the key wealth creation vehicle.

Of course, some family firms file for bankruptcy. Others are sold because the family owners are unable to compete in the market. Still others don't last because the family quarrels over how the business should be run.

Family business educators must teach the public that there is another end of the continuum—sales of a business that do not represent a family's failure, but rather are part of its transition to a new kind of family enterprise.






 Copyright 2014 by Family Business Magazine. This article may not be posted online or reproduced in any form, including photocopy, without permission from the publisher. For reprint information, contact

Article categories: 
Print / Download
May/June 2014


  • Haws Corporation family governance builders

    Haws, based in Sparks, Nev., and part of Traynor Family Enterprise, was founded in 1906 with the invention of the drinking fountain. The company today provides hy...

  • Trustees must build rapport with younger beneficiaries

    When 28-year-old Brady lost his mother to a sudden illness, in addition to grief and loss came questions about how to manage a large trust created by his mother. The mother’s estate plan distribu...

  • Family cleaning brand remains untarnished

    Alison Gutterman does not like to clean. Some people do, she realizes, but she’s not one of them. That’s funny, because her family owns Jelmar, the Skokie, Ill.-based company behind CLR and Rus...

  • Tips on interviewing financial advisers

    Do your homework
    • Determine your advisory needs. Do you require financial planning, estate planning and trust services? Will you need lending, insurance, philanthropic and ta...